Category: Court Decisions

Overcoming the Presumption of Joint Title – Convenience Property

May 31, 2014 | Court Decisions, Legal Perspective

Icon for author Brian Vertz Brian Vertz

A Pennsylvania resident who is pursuing a divorce might be concerned about property that is titled in their name for the convenience of a family member, like an elderly parent or a child who has poor credit. A new decision of the Superior Court (unpublished) outlines a legal argument for keeping that property out of the hands of the estranged spouse.  In Werdenbaugh v. Werdenbaugh, No. 1306 MDA 2013 (May 29, 2013), […]

Read More

Suspicion of Fraud Will Not Defeat Divorce Settlement Agreement

Couples who have settled their divorce in Pennsylvania may recall that divorce settlement agreements are final and enforceable only if there has been a full and fair disclosure of marital assets. A recent decision of the Pennsylvania Superior Court tests this principle in a case where one spouse suspected that her husband may have been less than honest in disclosing his net worth. In Ford v. Ford, the wife petitioned […]

Read More

Child Custody Alienation Tactics Backfire

April 10, 2014 | Child Custody, Court Decisions, Legal Perspective

Icon for author Brian Vertz Brian Vertz

Parents who are facing custody disputes in Pennsylvania may be interested in understanding how child alienation tactics are viewed by judges in Pennsylvania courts. A recent decision of the Pennsylvania Superior Court (unpublished) illustrates the perils that may befall a parent who engages in alienation tactics.  In B.E. v. D.N., No. 1894 EDA 2013 (April 9, 2014), a mother lost custody of her children, ages 12 and 9, when the […]

Read More

16-Factor Custody Analysis Not Always Required, Says Superior Court of PA

February 04, 2014 | Child Custody, Court Decisions, Legal Perspective

Icon for author Brian Vertz Brian Vertz

Presumably, opinions of the Superior Court are published when, in the estimation of the Court, they articulate important principles of jurisprudence. So, the Superior Court was sending a message to family law practitioners when it chose to publish M.O. v. J.T.R., 2014 Pa.Super. 15 (February 4, 2014). M.O. is a custody case in which Mother and Father were divorced parents of one emancipated daughter and two minor sons.  When they […]

Read More

Prenup Interpretation is Controlled by Context

January 20, 2014 | Court Decisions, Legal Perspective, Prenuptial Agreements

Icon for author Brian Vertz Brian Vertz

A non-precedential decision of the Superior Court, Morabito v. Morabito, No. 878 WDA 2013 (January 17, 2014) might provide a little window into the minds of our judiciary when interpreting prenuptial agreements.  The marriage in this case lasted nearly twenty years before the wife filed a complaint in divorce.  Wife initially challenged the validity of the prenup, but soon conceded that it was valid and enforceable. What Husband and Wife […]

Read More

School Must Bus Kids to Both Parents’ Homes in Shared Custody Case

January 13, 2014 | Child Custody, Court Decisions, Legal Perspective

Icon for author Brian Vertz Brian Vertz

In Watts v. Mannheim Twp. S.D., No. 935 C.D. 2013 (January 7, 2014), the Commonwealth Court was confronted with the issue of whether a school district must provide bus service to the homes of both parents who share custody of their children on a week on-week off basis. The school district filed the appeal, arguing that the School Code does not require it to provide transportation to a resident pupil to and from […]

Read More

Contact Us